Business Community

A Rack of Free Coats, a Shop Dog Named Frida and $15 Bag Days: How El Thrift Store Became a Main Street Favorite in Its First Year

Nadine Maté opened El Thrift Store at 218 Main St. a year ago with prices from a quarter to about $60, a ceiling full of umbrellas and a promise that everyone is welcome. Here’s what to shop for, what regulars say, and the events coming up this week.

The glass front doors of El Thrift Store at 218 Main St. in East Haven, painted with the shop name and autumn leaves, with colorful umbrellas hanging inside

EAST HAVEN — Walk through the glass doors at 218 Main St. and the first thing most people do is look up. A canopy of open umbrellas, in pink, yellow, teal and orange, hangs from the ceiling of the little entryway, and a rainbow flag is painted along the wall. Then comes the second surprise: just about everything in the shop beyond it costs less than lunch.

Colorful open umbrellas hang from the ceiling over the entry of El Thrift Store on Main Street in East Haven, beside a painted rainbow wall

That’s El Thrift Store, the secondhand and consignment shop Nadine Maté opened at the end of October 2025. A year later, it has become one of those places East Haven people tell their friends about: a store with a constantly changing mix of clothes, jewelry, dishes and decor, a shop dog named Frida, a calendar full of community nights, and an owner who once wheeled out a rack of free coats because, as the shop put it, “No one should be cold.”

The owner behind the umbrellas

Nadine, who also goes by Nadine Mate-Piovanetti, built El Thrift Store as a Puerto Rican, woman-owned and LGBTQ+-owned business, and she has said from the start that the welcome matters as much as the merchandise.

“I wanted to create a space where people [could] come together and express themselves,” she told The Comet, the East Haven High School student newspaper, in a feature last spring. “The world is full of hate and I wanted to make people feel comfortable.”

She told the student reporter that turning the idea into a real store took about six months, from choosing the location, name and concept to figuring out where the merchandise would come from. Setting up the shop itself took about three months. Her advice for anyone thinking about opening a business is the kind you could hang on the wall: “It is a very scary process, but just do it because it is worth it in the end. … Be proud of how scared you are and just do it.”

The town and the East Haven Chamber of Commerce held a ribbon cutting for the shop in November 2025. On her events page, Nadine sums up the mission in one line: she wants “a space filled with events for everyone to join and form a community, where you can feel safe to express yourself and have fun doing it.”

Cheap, cheerful and good for the planet

Everything at El Thrift Store comes from donations, and Nadine has kept the prices low on purpose. “With the state of the world and how expensive it is, I wanted to sell items at an affordable and reasonable price,” she told The Comet, adding that items in the store run from about 25 cents to about $60.

Donating is easy: you walk in and drop things off. When she spoke to The Comet, Nadine was also giving donors 20% off whatever they bought that same day. “I’m just trying to repurpose everything I can,” she said.

Customers notice the effort. “Stop fast fashion, help reduce waste, and support a local business all in one stop!” Kimberly wrote in a five-star Google review this fall. The shop holds a 4.7-star rating on Google, and the topics Google pulls out of its reviews include “friendly owner,” “jewelry” and “shop dog.”

The front window of El Thrift Store in East Haven, with mannequins in thrifted outfits, a traffic-light display and a lit OPEN sign

What to shop for

The stock turns over constantly, so no two visits look the same. These are the sections regulars keep coming back to.

Clothing and shoes. Long racks of jackets, shirts, pants and dresses fill the back of the store, with baskets of folded tees up front. Joy wrote that she has “gotten exceptional clothes and home goods” there and called it the “best thrift store in the New Haven area.”

Racks of secondhand jackets, shirts and pants line the aisles inside El Thrift Store in East Haven, with a basket of folded T-shirts in front

Hats, ties and accessories. One wall is a mini department store of its own: knit hats, ball caps, neckties, scarves, bags and even a couple of golf bags, around a vintage mirror and dresser.

A wall of knit hats, baseball caps, neckties and accessories around a wooden dresser and mirror at El Thrift Store

Jewelry. Jewelry is one of the most-mentioned finds in the shop’s reviews. Sophia went to a $15 fill-a-bag day and “found a beautiful necklace, 10/10 would recommend,” and Michael listed “clothes and jewelry, to vases, and so much more” among the things that made it his “new to-go place.”

A gold-tone teardrop pendant necklace laid on a red, white and black patterned fabric, a find from El Thrift Store

Glassware, dishes and home goods. Shelves of cobalt and colored glass, stacks of plates, pitchers, clocks, candlesticks and kitchen tools fill the front of the store, along with houseplants and a few pieces of furniture. Michael called the place “very whimsical, with its striking set ups and colorful decorations.”

A shopper browses wooden shelves of glassware, dishes and home goods at El Thrift Store, beside a table set with candles and plants
Red glass pitchers, glasses, plates and plants on display shelves at El Thrift Store in East Haven

Holiday decor. With the holidays coming, a decorated tree now anchors a display of baskets, bags and seasonal pieces, worth a look for anyone hunting for gifts on a budget.

A decorated Christmas tree beside a wooden table with baskets of purses and wallets and a driftwood sculpture at El Thrift Store

Work by local makers. Nadine also makes room for small local businesses. “I also support local businesses if they are interested in selling their work,” she told The Comet, and candles, jewelry and other handmade goods share the shelves. Nikki called it “a great place to get one-of-a-kind jewelry, soaps and other miscellaneous treasures from local small business owners.”

A store that throws a party

What really sets El Thrift Store apart is how much happens there after you’ve finished shopping. Nadine runs regular fill-a-bag days, when shoppers pay $15 and take home whatever fits in the bag. “Constantly changing inventory of unique secondhand everything,” Nikki wrote two weeks ago. “El Thrift Store also runs fun events and fill-a-bag days. Highly recommend!”

On the first Sunday of every month at 5 p.m., the store hosts the East Haven Pride Book Club, led by Shannon Prindle of East Haven Pride. It’s free, there’s food and drinks, and the organizers’ pitch is simple: “Did we mention this is all at a thrift store?” The next meeting is Sunday, Dec. 6.

This afternoon, Saturday, Nov. 21, from 4 to 6 p.m., the shop and CT Sapphic Collective host a free Sapphic Item Swap: bring five to 10 gently used, clean items and leave with something new, with DJs playing the whole time. RSVP is requested on the event page.

And on Saturday, Nov. 28, the day after Black Friday, you can paint your own tote bag from 2 to 6 p.m. for $15 a tote, then fill it with thrifted finds. There’s no time limit, and the event is open to all ages.

Flyer for Paint Your Own Tote Bag at El Thrift Store, Nov. 28, 2 to 6 p.m., $15 per tote, 218 Main St., East Haven

Kindness off the rack

The moment that put El Thrift Store on a lot of people’s radar came last January, during a stretch of bitter cold before a winter storm. The shop posted on the Good Things About East Haven Facebook group that it had set out a rack of jackets and long-sleeve shirts, free for anyone who needed them, with blankets, gloves and socks next to it. “No one should be cold,” the post said. It drew more than 600 likes and more than 100 comments, Patch reported.

Reviewers say the generosity is a habit. Joy wrote that Nadine “shares surplus donations with local charities,” and called her “very kind & helpful.” This holiday season, the shop is also one of the drop-off spots for the Kindness 4 Kids East Haven toy drive.

Then there’s Frida, the shop dog, who has her own fan club in the reviews. Joy gave “bonus points for the sweetest shop dog ever, Frida!!”

If you go

El Thrift Store is at 218 Main St., East Haven. The sign in the front window lists hours of Wednesday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 7 p.m., and Sunday from 11 a.m.; the shop is closed Monday and Tuesday. Its Google listing shows it closed on Thanksgiving Day. Donations are accepted in the store. For new arrivals, events and fill-a-bag days, follow @elthriftstore on Instagram or the shop’s Facebook page, and see upcoming events on Nadine’s Eventbrite page.

Want East Haven news in your inbox? The East Haven Courier newsletter is coming soon. Email news@easthavencourier.com with “Newsletter” in the subject line to get on the list.

Got a tip? Email news@easthavencourier.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *